I honestly thought I was helping. I mean, I knew there would be the usual dead cats chucked into my replies, race-hustling and Jew-hating anons lining up like good little bots to do the bidding of the algorithms, but I honestly thought the thoughtful Christians and especially pastors would seize the rope I was handing them and there would be a lot more of that old pastime known as bonhomie.
But alas, there was less bonhomie than expected. The help I offered? I said that a nation is a covenanted people. To this I was accused of theologizing propositionalism. Which, if I am following the argument, means I am a warmed-over liberal. That I’m a Hobbesian, Lockean, and Rousseauian slug, trying to revitalize and baptize social contracts. As one of my interlocutors put it, I have “put a sanctified veneer on the wicked egalitarian, feminist humanism.” Jeepers.
I would also like to say, Crikey.
I take it you haven’t read Heinrich Bullinger? What about Althusius or Vindiciae Contra Tyrannos? What about Lex Rex? What about something more recent like Glenn Moots’s Politics Reformed: The Anglo-American Legacy of Covenant Theology?
Well, here’s a brief explainer.
What Is a Covenanted People?
It is a people bound together by solemn bonds of loyalty, obligation, land, law, worship, history, culture, and blood — all under God. And it’s important to underline the fact that this covenantal nature is embedded in the creation covenant. It is what people do relatively naturally, without thinking about it, because we are made in God’s image and because God created us for society. We are in fact political animals like Aristotle said. But the Bible gives us God’s name for this instinct for belonging, loyalty — these customs and structures of community (and ultimately nations): covenant.
When Scripture speaks of nations (Greek ethnē, Hebrew goyim), it speaks of peoples God deals with as whole bodies. That bond often begins in the union of families and tribes, but it is a real status before God. He sees nations as bodies of people, and because they are made in His image, all that they do as nations is loaded with ethical and moral meaning. And that meaning is directly connected to a nation’s relationship to God: everything is personal to God – which again, the Bible calls “covenantal.” Everything relates to God personally.
While blood and genetics have obviously always been part of that, the Bible clearly teaches that blood and genes are not determinative of God’s blessing (more on this below). Fruitfulness, industry, intelligence, and prosperity are not primarily the results of genes and lineage, but of covenant blessings, of how people have responded to the gifts of God, whether in gratitude and obedience or ingratitude and rebellion.
Israel and the Nations
This covenantal identity was the explicit status of Israel as the special covenanted people of God, but Old Testament Israel was also, in part, a type of what God expected of all the nations. Israel was a light to the nations not only as the line of promise, through whom would come the Savior, but as a revelation of what nations simply are — namely, covenanted people owing God fealty and obedience, societies of friendship and justice under God’s law.
This covenantal identity was implied in the Noahic covenant (Gen. 9), from which all families and nations descend (Gen. 10). But it is also clearly implied in the Abrahamic covenant: “In thy seed shall all the nations of the earth be blessed” (Gen. 22:18). All the nations will ultimately participate in the covenant blessings of Abraham’s seed. This is true with regard to the spiritual kingdom of Christ coming to all the nations for salvation, but it is also true of the nations as nations, since the nations (as political and cultural entities) will bring their glories into the New Jerusalem (Rev. 21:24–26). Christ commissioned His church to disciple the nations – which includes teaching them how to be blessed and excellent nations (Matt. 28:19), and at the end John sees a multitude from every nation, kindred, people, and tongue before the throne (Rev. 7:9). The spiritual kingdom of Christ does not obliterate nations; it teaches and disciples nations to become true nations, righteous nations — with the true God as their Lord.
A Double Covenant
The Bible teaches that nations consist of a dual covenant — one between God and the ruler(s) and people, and another between the ruler(s) and the people. The first consists of the laws and obligations established by God for all nations; the second consists of the obligations of the particular rulers and people to adhere to those laws. Romans 13 clearly teaches that no ruler has authority apart from the sovereign will of God (Rom. 13:1). Thus, even pagan nations and rulers are in covenant “under God” in this sense. There is no political power apart from the true and living God. He raises up kings and nations, and He pushes them down and scatters them. He is the One who sets the boundaries of nations (Acts 17:26). They exist by His decree, and therefore, they owe Him obedience, and if they would have His blessing, they must abide by His laws and ways. Again, the Bible calls that “covenant” obligation.
We see this in 2 Kings 11:17: “And Jehoiada made a covenant between the LORD and the king and the people, that they should be the LORD’S people; between the king also and the people.” Philippe Duplessis-Mornay (“Junius Brutus”) says the same thing in Vindiciae Contra Tyrannos (1579): “there was a double covenant treated of, to wit, ‘between God and the king’; and ‘between God and the people.’” Elsewhere he says the people “have contracted two covenants, and taken two oaths. The first and most ancient is with God, to whom the people have sworn to be His people; the second is with the king, to whom the people have promised obedience.” Later, Mornay cites Augustine’s City of God (IV.4 and XIX.21), where it says that where there is no justice there is no commonwealth. And what is justice besides what God requires is due to Himself, the rulers, and the people in their respective stations? And what are these obligations before God but covenant obligations?
This is not new with Mornay. Johannes Althusius called the commonwealth a covenanted association, and Samuel Rutherford’s Lex Rex argued that the law, not the king, is sovereign, and that king and people are bound to one another under God – again, the Scottish “Covenanters” called this a national covenant.
This applies to pagan nations as well. Pagan nations are at least held to the Noahic covenant (Gen. 9, and see Isa. 24:5), but Psalm 2 says pagan nations have an obligation to submit to God’s Messiah, and Paul says that God now “commandeth all men every where to repent” (Acts 17:30). All nations, even pagan nations, are under covenant obligation to submit to Christ because He is risen from the dead. And until they do, they are breaking covenant.
Not a Social Contract
These covenant obligations of nations go back to the covenants with Adam and Noah. All people always exist in various covenantal bonds and obligations: marriage, families, tribes, and nations, even various land and business deals. There is no non-covenantal primitive “state of nature.” Covenant theology is not warmed over social contract theory.
All of creation exists by the Word of God, and it exists and has its being precisely because God is a covenant-keeping God. God continuously and personally upholds all things by His Word so that they are what they are. And we keep this creational covenant with God by receiving what He has made with gratitude and using what He has made obediently and in accordance with the purposes for which it was made. Some of this happens instinctively and informally, but it applies to marriage, family, nations, etc. Everything is covenantal in this general sense because everything relates to God personally. It is what He says it is, and its proper use is what He says it is. And we either live in obedience to those covenant obligations or not, whether consciously or unconsciously.
This is also why a covenanted people is not a “propositional nation,” as though a nation were a mere cerebral club of united brains and thoughts (or creed). Social contract theory going back to Hobbes, Locke, and Rousseau theorized a blank state of nature (pun intended) out of which social obligations were invented out of nothing (poof) and then men entered into voluntary associations. Ahem, Rutherford would like a word. As would Bullinger and Calvin. That is not a covenant in the biblical sense of the word. Not hardly.
A covenant is men acknowledging obligations God has already placed on them, through birth, land, history, and worship, and sealing them with oaths, signs, blessings, and curses. Propositions and contracts can be voluntarily signed by anyone and entered or exited freely. Covenants are embedded in nature itself and exist with and without explicit oaths for all involved. Some covenants may be voluntary, but they are always solemn because their stipulations and obligations are before the Lord, and God is always a party to them and is the sovereign enforcer of the obligations resident in the nature of the covenant. Abraham took the oath, but all the males in his household were inducted and thereby obligated: both sons and servants. Adam stood for all of us, even though none of us were there, we are still obligated to the Dominion Mandate while suffering the curse of sin and death. Children are entailed in the marriage covenant. And this, incidentally, answers the charge of egalitarianism. No, covenants always have heads/representatives: Adam, Abraham, fathers, husbands, and kings who stand for and answer for those under them. Whatever covenant theology is, it is not “egalitarian, feminist humanism.”
Covenants Made and Renewed
And yet, throughout Scripture we see new covenants made or old covenants renewed. When a new marriage comes into being, a new covenant is formed. When a new nation comes into being, a new covenant is formed. However, sometimes, God (or people) may find it fitting to renew covenant. God remembered His covenant with Abraham and renewed His covenant with Israel at Sinai (Ex. 2:24; 6:4–8). The Sinai covenant was not, properly speaking, a “new” covenant; it was a renewal of the covenant made with Abraham. But God was essentially making formal and explicit what He had already done through the Exodus.
When Jehoiada made the covenant with young Joash and the people, Israel (Judah) was already a nation, but the covenant had been severely strained, if not broken, and so it was fitting for that national covenant to be renewed (2 Kgs. 11:17). Josiah did the same when the book of the law was found (2 Kgs. 23:1–3), and Nehemiah did it again (Neh. 9–10).
But in every case, our human covenants, whether new covenants or covenants renewed, are merely submitting to and publicly acknowledging what God has done in history and what He is doing now. God brings a man and woman together, and we acknowledge His sovereign act by having a wedding ceremony. He gives a covenant child to a Christian family, and we acknowledge God’s prior claim on that holy child by baptizing him – but he already belonged to God. God establishes a new nation, and we write a constitution and establish new customs, codify laws, and live together in society. It all goes back to Adam, and he was created in relationship to God and immediately given his wife. Nations emerge from these pre-political covenants of marriage, family, and tribe.
What About Blood?
So what about blood? Scripture says, God “hath made of one blood all nations of men for to dwell on all the face of the earth, and hath determined the times before appointed, and the bounds of their habitation” (Acts 17:26). Common descent, distinct peoples and cultures, and God-appointed boundaries are all there: our fathers and our ancestry are gifts to be received with gratitude and honored, never despised (Ex. 20:12). So globalist hatred of white people (or of any people for their ancestry) is out.
But the covenant has always been permeable. Abraham’s covenant took in the 318 man militia born in his house and the servants bought with money, none of them his kin (Gen. 14:14; 17:12–13). A mixed multitude came out of Egypt with Israel (Ex. 12:38), and a stranger who was circumcised was “as one that is born in the land” (Ex. 12:48–49). Caleb was a Kenizzite. Rahab and Ruth came in, and both are in the line of Christ (Matt. 1:5). Blood is part of what a nation is, but it is not what makes a nation a nation, much less the color of your skin.
But this permeability does not mean boundless or infinitely malleable. To enter a covenant is to take on its obligations: its God, its laws, its loyalties. Ruth the Moabitess became an Israelite by swearing fealty to Naomi’s God and people and land (Ruth 1:16–17). A stranger who joins the national covenant and keeps covenant is a neighbor and fellow citizen – just as in Israel. However, masses of immigrants who come in without any intention of joining our national covenant are not joining a nation; they are invading it. I find the covenantal definition of a nation extremely helpful in sorting through the questions of race, ethnicity, and immigration.
Conclusion: Christian Nationalism & the American Covenant
Nationalism is simply the belief that nations are to be preferred to tribes or empires. Tribalism tends to descend into factionalism, and empires descend into tyranny (and globalism is just imperial aspirations with better branding). Nations are the union of tribes, as we see in the nation of Israel and the American nation (from colonies). “Christian nationalism” is simply the belief that nations cannot have the blessing of God apart from submission to Jesus Christ. Blessed is that nation whose God is the Lord (Ps. 33:12).
As Glenn Moots and others have demonstrated, America began as a covenanted people. King George called the American War for Independence the “Presbyterian Rebellion” not because we were mostly a nation that baptized babies (although we were). His point was that it was the old specter of the Scottish Covenanters. The colonies were knit together by charters and compacts “in the name of God,” and we united as ‘one nation under God.’ Our national covenant has been strained to the point of breaking for a long time. But what our Protestant fathers taught is that what Jehoiada, Josiah, and Nehemiah did, we can also do: confess our sins, renew covenant, and teach our children to keep it.

Leave a Reply