Strangers in our Gates
I don’t really know much about politics. And I sure don’t know anything about immigration law. But frankly, the people whining about all this illegal immigration sound like greedy cranks. If Mexicans or Hispanics work harder and are willing to take less for their work than the average lazy American, then I think we’d be better off. Of course, I’m not advocating breaking the law, and I don’t even know what the law is, by the way. But if a fellow is willing to work hard to provide for his family, and he thinks he can do that in the States, I say let him in.
To speak in crass terms: more competition tends to encourage ingenuity, hard work and it checks inflation. The whole thing also seems like a gross misunderstanding of value. Remember, it’s people (and the work they do) who are valuable. Money is only worth as much as it buys. Money is the yard stick not the object being measured. The thing being measured, the thing of value, is a man or woman and the increase of their labors. That means that every immigrant that does better work than a current resident is more valuable.
And on a more theological level, throughout the Scriptures, God defends and provides for the stranger and the sojourner, and He commands us to do the same.
Rick Capezza says
Amen!
There’s a post I’ve nearly written fifty times.
Rebekah says
Amen!
ElizabethDemeusy says
In a free market, I would agree with you. Unfortunately, our government provides tax-funded services (primarily health care and K-12 education). In addition, taxes fund the upkeep and expansion of roads, freeways and emergency services (police & fire). Immigrants who are here illegally do not contribute taxes to fund those services, but they may not be denied access to those services.
Immigrants who are here legally, earn a small salary and pay a modest amount of taxes are not only eligible for those services, but they can receive various forms of supplemental income from state, local, and federal governments. This is a transactional cost that is forgotten in most economic analyses of immigration. Immigrants may be willing to perform some jobs more cheaply than American workers, but their eligibility for welfare benefits and social services increases the cost of relying on immigrant workers.